• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Peter's Fishery

At Peter's Fishery, seafood takes center stage, with a commitment to freshness and flavor that delights every palate. Nestled in Matawan, NJ, this casual eatery boasts a robust menu, from classic fried platters to creative contemporary dishes like shrimp and avocado spring rolls. The inviting ambiance, enhanced by clean, refreshing scents, sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. With options for takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, the fishery caters to families and friends alike, ensuring every visit is memorable. Guests rave about the hearty portions, attentive service, and the charm that makes this hidden gem a must-visit in the area.

Peter's Fishery: Reviews & Ratings

cicero m.
cicero m.

All around good. Good food Good prices Good service Good quantity Lunch menu only good on weekdays so the prices are slightly elevated on weekends. Chowders were really good. We had Caribbean and New England. Very tasty.

Shane W.
Shane W.

I've lived within walking distance of the fishery for months now but finally had an opportunity to try this place out. My wife hates seafood which is sort of why we avoided it. But I think it's going to be a lot more difficult to keep that trend going For my first visit I had stuffed flounder with traditional sides (baked potato and broccoli). The flounder was stuffed with crabmeat which I thought was delicious. But it did drown out some of the flounder taste so I'm not sure if that was good or bad. The service was pretty good. The waitress took the time to review the robust menu with me - tons of different seafood options (land lovers menu too for people like my wife). She also brought over some samples of appetizers to give me an idea of what their dishes look like. For a small, diner-like place, this place is certainly a gem. But shying away from giving this place 5 stars only because I haven't tried other menu items.

Donna P.
Donna P.

Our usual take out fishery is not open on Monday and we really wanted fish. Use to work in the area and went here many years, so I traveled a little extra to get dinner Tonight. Called in my order and it was ready in ten minutes. Great thing about this place is they offer fried and broiled seafood. Broiled is a great thing if you are gluten free, so I really enjoyed my platter. The fried shrimp is butterflied. Choice of a side, coleslaw, cocktail and tarter. My family felt the food was really great. Service was pleasant upon walking in. Many pluses: you can call in your order, have broiled orseafood, choice of sides, take credit cards, have a dinning room if you want to eat in, seafood counter if you want to make your own at home and own parking lot. Will definitely visit again.

Evangelina T.
Evangelina T.

What a change! It's been a while since I had been to peters fishery but was in the area the other day to order takeout for some friends visiting. I don't know if it is new management but a lot of things changed. There are fresh flowers throughout the restaurant and it has a really nice clean air smell. My biggest pet peeve is walking into a restaurant and stinking of food afterward, but it smelled clean in there. The menu looks very different. I noticed that the same fried combination platters are still available but there was a lot of fun appetizers and a bistro type menu and a lot of new salads. We ordered this shrimp and avocado spring roll app that was incredible. Our entrees were really good and tasted fresh. I had a shrimp and chorizo dish that was so delicious and my husband had the stuffed shrimp. We also got a beet and avocado salad that was really good as well. The portion sizes are large so we had a lot leftover. We can't wait to go back and try something else now. Keep up the good work Petes fishery!!!

Zao Z.
Zao Z.

I had the lobster crepe and the manhatten clam chowder. I also tried a bit of my friend's lobster bisque and flounder sandwich. All the food was pretty good but I was disappointed with the portion of the lobster crepe. The crepe was tiny, it was more of a very small tortilla. the sandwich was huge I think they should expand the menu as it is heavily centered on fish and chips. I wish there were other items. Keep in mind I went here for lunch; I am hoping their dinner menu is more comprehensive. Service was decent Decor is like a "upscale diner"(i know it is a oxymoron)

Location

Welcome to Peter's Fishery, a true gem nestled along the bustling NJ-34 in Matawan. Specializing in seafood, this casual eatery offers a delightful culinary experience for both seafood lovers and those who prefer land-based options.

Peter's Fishery makes dining a breeze with its range of utilities:

  • Takes reservations
  • Offers takeout and delivery
  • Accepts credit cards and Apple Pay
  • Casual atmosphere with outdoor seating
  • Family-friendly, with options suitable for kids
  • Good for groups, complete with on-site parking and bike parking
  • Destined to satisfy lunch and dinner cravings
  • Alcohol available, enhancing your dining experience

Feedback from the community reveals the essence of Peter's Fishery. Customers rave about the tasty chowders, particularly the Caribbean and New England varieties. The portions are generous, and the prices remain reasonable, especially on weekdays.

One reviewer, *Shane W.*, shared a heartwarming experience. On his inaugural visit, he savored a stuffed flounder combined with baked potatoes and broccoli. The crabmeat stuffing was both flavorful and filling, though it did steal the show from the flounder itself. The robust menu impressed him, offering everything from perfectly fried seafood to delightful starters.

Another visitor, *Donna P.*, enjoyed the convenience of quick takeout and praised the menu’s versatility, highlighting the availability of both fried and broiled options, which are fantastic for gluten-free diners. Her family relished their meal, further emphasizing the friendly service that greets every patron.

An inspired *Evangelina T.* noted the recent improvements in ambiance and menu variety. Fresh flowers adorned the space, and the introduction of innovative dishes, like shrimp and avocado spring rolls, showcased a modern twist. With large portion sizes, her love for seafood was rekindled, promising a return visit to explore further culinary delights.

In a nutshell, Peter's Fishery exemplifies a welcoming community vibe paired with an expansive menu designed to cater to all tastes—from the seafood connoisseur to the occasional diners. Whether you choose to dine in the lively atmosphere or opt for the convenience of takeout, every visit is sure to leave a lasting impression. So, why wait? Discover the taste of the ocean at Peter's Fishery!